Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 15, 2026

When Education Forgot the Hands

June 25, 2014, Flashback

"We had adopted the liberal model of education in which we gave much preference to knowledge and neglected the importance of skills... we scissor the importance of the dignity of labour and the teachings of Lord Krishna and Shri Guru Nanak Dev." 

— Sudhir Singh


Twelve years later, this flashback feels less like a memory and more like a prophecy.

We did exactly what I already talked about. We built an education system that taught our children how to describe work, but not how to do work. Degrees became more valuable than dexterity. A child who could write a 500-word essay on a carpenter was considered more educated than the carpenter himself!

And the biggest adversity is that no one wants to do menial work anymore.

Not because the work is undignified, but because we made education undignified for work. We taught productivity as a PowerPoint slide, not as sweat on the forehead.

This is where we cut ourselves off from our own roots:

1. Lord Krishna as the Karmayogi: In the Gita, Krishna never glorifies mere contemplation. He glorifies nishkam karma - skilled, dedicated action. Arjuna was not asked to just read about archery, he was asked to pick up the Gandiva and fight.

2. Shri Guru Nanak Dev as the Kirti Karni: "Kirat Karo" i.e. earn through honest labour - was placed alongside Naam Japo and Vand Chhako. Labour was not menial; it was spiritual. The langar was not served by degrees, it was served by hands.

Our old, skill-based model of education understood this. The liberal model we adopted replaced the Aashrams based on pragmatic approach with the classroom, and the guru with the textbook. Yes, now textbooks are more important than the Guru because their first responsibility is to complete syllabus. Syllabus!

Today, as India talks about Skill India, NEP 2020, and vocational training from Class 6, we are essentially trying to go back to what we left. We are trying to re-stitch the dignity of labour that we once scissored away.

The question I raised in 2014 remains in 2026: Will we produce well informed clerks, or will we produce those who can elevate the society to its fullest? 

But to produce the latter, we need to work on individuality first...


Monday, August 17, 2026

Are We Addicted to Our Problems?

Most of us are attached to our problems.  


Sounds strange? But think about it. We complain about them, talk about them, carry them with us — and yet we don’t let them go. Sometimes, we even create new ones.  


One big reason behind this is procrastination. And procrastination, I feel, is often the side effect of over-optimism.  


When we delay work, deep inside we feel: “I’ll manage it at the eleventh hour. I’m smart enough. I’ve done it before.”  

That’s not just confidence. That’s over-confidence. We trust our last-minute magic more than our planning.


But not every delay comes from ego.  

Sometimes we procrastinate because we are stressed. The task feels too heavy.  

Sometimes we procrastinate because we’ve lost interest. The work no longer excites us.  


So the problem isn’t just “laziness”. The problem is: we don’t pause to ask why we are delaying.


We need to analyse ourselves deeply.  

Which category do I fall into?  

Category 1: Am I delaying because I’m over-confident?  

Category 2: Am I delaying because I’m overwhelmed?  

Or 

Category 3: Am I delaying because my heart is no longer in it?  


Once we know the root, we can fix it.  

I. Over-confidence needs discipline.  

II. Stress needs rest and breakdown of tasks.  

III. Loss of interest needs honesty — maybe it’s time to change direction.  


Problems will come. But let’s not get attached to them.  

And let’s not hide behind “I’ll do it later.”  


Because later rarely comes.  

The eleventh hour only teaches us panic, not progress.



Saturday, August 15, 2026

What True Independence Means


Flashback, 15 Aug. 2016  

"Independent is one who has an independent attitude." 

~ Sudhir Singh


On Independence Day, we celebrate freedom from rulers but are we free within?


True independence isn’t just about a flag or a date. It’s about an attitude.  


An independent attitude is thinking from your own perspective, even when media, people, community and society are trying to manipulate you. You are independent when you can see behind the curtain of the big play. You are independent when your opinions are your own, not the borrowed one. It’s saying “no” when something doesn’t align with your values, and “yes” when it scares you but you feel it's right.


Countries become independent when people develop independent attitude. A nation of dependent minds will always look for someone to lead, fix, or rescue them.  

A nation of independent attitudes builds, questions, creates their own ideas, develop their own perspectives and stands tall.


This 15th August, let’s go beyond parades.  

Let’s check one thing: Where in my life am I still waiting for permission?  


Because independence begins the day you decide: I will think, choose, and act for myself.





Sunday, January 6, 2019

Satire for social Structure

This world is quite weird especially our country India and its social as well as political structure.  First, we ran after urbanization and adopted the model of western culture blindly.  We start neglecting the village life and village culture due to our confined gullible set of mind. And then we have given a new name to the old profession i.e. Skill development. 

Before independence, our countrymen gave much emphasis on vocational education but Britishers taught us a new way of living i.e. babu culture. They circumscribed our skill and mentality at the level of slavery. 

Now again we have been introduced the old concept in a new frame.  It will not be exaggerating and over-emphasising if in future many colleges and universities will be introducing the courses like this;

Bachelor in Agricultural management. (B.A.M)

Masters in Agricultural management.  (M.A.M)

Bachelor in Shoe Making (B.S.M)

Masters in Shoe Making (M.S.M)

Advance Diploma in pot making (A.D.P.M)

Post graduation diploma in pot making (P.G.D.P.M)

#Please stop commercializing Education

Thursday, August 17, 2017

Uses of Articles

*Use of Definite and Indefinite Article before consonants and vowels*
(By - Sudhir Singh)


Definite Articles are those which emphasise things, places and persons already known to us whereas in an Indefinite Articles we aren't much aware about things, places and persons. 



That's why in definite articles we prefer */tha/*  and */thee/* pronunciation  for *consonants* and *vowels* sounds  respectively as *the* is used for things, places, persons already known to us or something which is very much famous.


Similarly when we talk about an Indefinite Articles then we are using *a* and *an* for *consonants* and *vowels* respectively as we don't have ample of previous information regarding things, places and persons.

Thursday, May 26, 2016

The Pseudo Ideology!!!.............???

      The Mortal Truth is something like a wrong statement, same is with education. Recently I was thinking about our present educational implementations in India.  As per my observation what I observed that we are very far from the definition of Education.  

  • Mahatma Gandhi Said:  "Knowledge lies in simplicity."
  • Swami Vivekananda Said: "Education is the manifestation of divine perfection already existing in human body."
  • Shankracharya Said: "Education is the realization of the self."
     But the question which is rising in front of me is: 
  • How many of us have such kind of Education?  
  • And in how many institution such kind of Education is provided? 
  •  Is it a truth or just a definition of Education?
  • How can this objective be obtained?
  • Why are we lacking to obtain this ultimate objective?
  • Who is responsible of it?
  • Who can take the responsibility?
  • How can students understand the true meaning of Education?
  • Is it a truth or just a statement?
  • What is the real truth in the screen?
  • How can be justify it?
  • Who can justify it?
  • What should be required for its improvement?
These are some of the questions which I think are able to expose the false reality of our education system.  The reality which is living in an ideology. 
     Now lets talk about child psychology and his or her needs:
In the present educational scenario child is left behind and only grades and marks has taken his place.  It seems that it is vanishing the individuality of a child!  Isn't it???
  • Why the child feel burdened?
  • Why the parents feel dissatisfied?
  • Why the teacher look like the real culprit?
  • Why the institutions are worried about grades and numbers?

Now lets see these question in a different way:
  • How the child feel burdened?
  • How the parents feel dissatisfied?
  • How the teacher look like the real culprit?
  • How the institutions are worried about grades and numbers?
We can see these question in another perspective:
  • Where the child feel burdened?
  • Where the parents feel dissatisfied?
  • Where the teacher look like the real culprit?
  • Where the institutions are worried about grades and numbers?
The answer of all these questions can be given in a one word i.e.
COMPETITION!!!
Any Questions???
?


  

Friday, May 6, 2016

CUMULATIVE RECORD (NON- TESTING TECHNIQUE)

CUMULATIVE RECORD:

The cumulative record is device for recording information about the student, which is collected from different sources over a period of time. These information are essential for guidance and counseling of the students.
According to Ruth Strang there are the following uses of cumulative records for the guidance program:
  • Holding conferences with parents about the student’s programs.
  • Adapting instruction in the classroom, students needs, abilities and interests.
  • Helping students to make important choice or decisions such as:
  • Choice of course
  • Change of course
  • Choice of vocational field
  • Decision to leave school
  • Helping students in solving their problems of adjustment in the school, home or society.
  • Supplying information to the youth employment service regarding student’s suitability for certain type of jobs.
DEFINITATIONS
  • According to Allen, “The cumulative record is defined as a record of information concerned with appraisal of the individual pupil-usually kept on a card kept in one place.”
  • According to Jane Warters, “All important information regarding a pupil observation interview, case study and other methods.”
According to Mure Thomas, “It is information about a pupil collected during a long period.”


IMPORTANCE OF CUMULATIVE RECORDS

  • Simple and complete information
  • Factual information
  • Secrecy
  • Full record
  • Based on all round development
  • Re- evaluation
  • Continuity
  • Group- based evaluation
  • Usefulness 
TYPES OF CUMULATIVE RECORDS
Simple card record:-  It is single sheet information recorded on both side.
  • Pocket folders:-  It is a folder with a number of pockets posted inside and different information can be kept.
  • Cumulative folder:-  This folder can keep maximum informatio. 
Conclusion 
      the cumulative records serve as a well arranged store- house of all the information regarding the students. It is based on factual information, and there is also need to mention secrecy of information. There should be the importance of usefulness of cumulative records so it may be used properly. It’s content should be proper and systematically. 

References

Valiya (2012)   "Guidance and counselling."
Bhatiya(2011)  "Educational Psychology."
Valiya (2012)   "Educational Psychology."

Saturday, April 30, 2016

Equality of Educational Opportunities


     What is Equality of Educational Opportunity?

One of the stark realities of human society is inequality or what the sociologists call social stratification.  It has been existing in some form or other in all societies.  In India inequality of educational opportunities is a reality that has been existing for generations.  In the traditional caste system education was the prerogative of the upper castes.  The British policy of providing English education to the elite resulted in direct neglect of mass education.  The British policy, therefore, accentuated the inequality of educational opportunities imposed by the traditional caste system.  In India, inequality of educational opportunities has been inherited from our past generations. 

       After independence we adopted a Constitution.  The Preamble of the Indian Constitution emphasizes equality of status and of opportunity.  Article 15 provides.  The State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex, place of birth or any of the advancement of women, children,  SC and ST.  In spite of all this inequality still exists.

What is Inequality?

Inequality means that certain individuals or groups in a society are in a relatively disadvantageous situation in regard to access to and possession of various societal resources such as wealth, power, education and occupation.  In the sphere of education some have no access to school, and some have limited access.  Some children get all the opportunities to receive education of the type they need.  Some children do not get the opportunity for receiving the basic education.  In some cases so many opportunities are available that children have to choose to decide.  In other cases children have no option than to accept what is even undesirable.

What is Equality?

To put in simple words, equality is said to exist only when inequality has been removed.  But in reality inequality is not totally eliminated.  Whatever measures may be taken to ensure equality, inequality will exist to some degree.  Thus what the programmes of equality do or can do is to narrow down the inequalities.  It means “elimination of that level or type of inequality which is considered undesirable or unacceptable within the society.”   Thus the pursuit of equality aims not at total equality in the philosophical sense, but at an equitable distribution societal resources.
      Modern society views education as an important societal resource and a means of achieving the goal of egalitarianism.  Education is looked upon as a means of raising the social status of an individual in various ways.   It is accepted as a basic human need to have a desirable quality of life.  Given equal opportunity for general, vocational, technical and professional education most citizens can have equal status in the society.  Education is often considered as an equalizer.

     Education can be expected to function as an equalizer in the context of equality of opportunity in education.  Equality of educational opportunities means that every child has a right to education.  No individual is deemed access to any level or type of education or is handicapped in educational achievements solely on account of his personal attributes or primordial identities.  “Equality of educational opportunities is one of the goals of the ideology of egalitarianism.  However, inequality of educational opportunities exists throughout the world and more so in India.

     These considerations imply that we have to give equal chance to every citizen for the development of his or her capacity or ability, and nothing should be allowed to obstruct one’s path of development.  Particularly special attention is to be given to the underprivileged, the disadvantaged, the disabled, women and other children from backward communities.

Need/ Importance of Equalization of Educational Opportunities:

The Education Commission (1964-66) has observed:  “One of the important social objectives of education is to equalize opportunity, enabling the backward of underprivileged classes and individuals to use education as lever for the improvement of their condition.  Every society that values social justice and is anxious to improve the lot of the common man and cultivate all available talent must ensure progressive equality of opportunity to all sections of the population.  This is the only guarantee for the building up of an egalitarian and Equality of educational opportunities. The observation of Kothari Commission indicates the need of importance of equalization of educational opportunities as follows:
I.It is needed for the establishment of an egalitarian society.
II.It is needed for the success of democracy.
III. It is needed to ensure social and economic development of our country.
IV.     It is needed to identify the talent in various fields.
V.  It is needed to develop human resources and to meet the man power needs of our country.
VI. It is needed to promote social justice.
VII. It is needed to minimize the educational gap between the privileged and the underprivileged.

Causes of Inequality in respect of education opportunities:

A large number of factors are responsible for inequality in respect of educational opportunities.  Some of the notable causes of inequality are as follows:

I. Absence of the National system of Education.  At present our eduation system has not been nationalized.  Both public  and private agencies are at work in the area of school Education is the greatest obstacle in the way of equality of educational opportunities.
II. Regional Imbalance:  There are regional imbalances in educational opportunities in different States, different districts and blocks.  There are areas where facilities for higher education are not available.  Even there are areas having no facility for elementary education.  In some areas primary schools exist, but they are incomplete.  In these areas boys and girls do not get equal opportunity for education. 
III. Poverty of Parents:  Poverty of parents is a major cause of inequality of educational opportunities.  Children from poor families fail to attend educational institutions where education/training is expensive.  Children from affluent families get all facilities which they need -  text books, work books, dress and everything which poor children do not get.
IV.   Differential Standard of Educational Institutions:  Children from poor families receive education in substandard institutions which are not properly equipped with teachers, teaching aids and apparatus.  Usually urban schools and colleges are of better standard than rural schools and colleges.  Differences in the standard of educational institutions ultimately cause inequality in the standard of students.
V.   Differences in the Home Environment:  Inequality also arises from differences in the home environment of children.  In most of the families parents are illiterate and their children are first generation learners.  These children do not get the needed encouragement, help and academic support from parents.  On the contrary children from educated families get all the support and encouragement from their parents for their education.  This causes inequality among children. 
VI.  Gender Disparity:  Another cause of educational inequality is the wide disparity between the education of boys and girls at all stages also causes inequality in all areas of education.   Usually parents value more and take care of education of their sons, which the girl child in the family is neglected.  The curriculum is also not suited to the needs and problems of the girls.  In many cases expectation of parents and teachers for their sons and daughters also vary.  Teachers’ expectation and parental expectation are reflected in children’s performance. 
VII.  Disparity between the Advantaged and the Disadvantaged:  Disparity between the upper class and lower class of the society is always been a crucial issue.  In the sphere of education also disparity exists between the advantaged community or the upper class and the disadvantaged community or the lower class.  Educational expansion and other educational measures are found mostly in advantaged communities and are meant for upper class children.  The disadvantaged groups, particularly the SC and ST are deprived of all developmental programmes.  Even in some cases such children do not have the opportunities for minimum education – elementary education.

References

Chaube, S.P (2006) "Foundations of Education", vikas publishing house pvt ltd, A-22, Sector-4, Noida- 201301 (up)
NCTE-2009




Sunday, April 17, 2016

My first discussion lesson during B.Ed.

https://www.facebook.com/sudhirsingh89/videos/783880508334404/?l=1387265156000593489

Wednesday, March 30, 2016

Learning and knowledge NCF-2005 Chapter 2 critical anlysis (learning with burden)

      This chapter establishes the facts that learning of a child should be done in natural condition and the child's learning should be natural as if he or she is learning the sitting and walking habits.  Most of the time in our day to day life we saw that children learn out of curiosity.  They actively engage with the world around them and tried to identify different objects with the help of their senses.
     Most of the time it has been seen that we create barrier for the natural learning of our children as we think that they are just wasting their time and energy.  But it is the process of their learning.  Though we call ourselves a great scholars but still we don't find: why our students are facing lot of problem while learning in schools?
Schools have their own criteria for checking their learning but their evaluation is useless as it is based on rank and number system not based on life experience.  Our evaluation techniques are not as good as we consider because it just check the cognitive development of a child.  Though NCF 2005 helps to check their affective and conative domain also but it is far from implementations.  The reason is the only touchstone for checking the abilities of students, schools and teachers are "Marks in 90s and above 90s."  Such a damn jock it is!  I am one of the students who never got more than 60% in my school life but still, my knowledge base is more than these students of 90s because my teachers also focus to strengthen my understanding abilities not cramming abilities.
     Here in this chapter, it has been emphasized that children are an active learner, therefore, the textbook culture should be avoided.  But tell me truly in how many schools learning is based on the active engagement of learners?  Rather students are forced to mug up things so that they can produce a good result which further helps the schools to sell their products.  After their studies in school when they enter colleges, they found completely different things.  They saw that teachers are just giving the lectures and doing the debates in class and then they find themselves nowhere.  
     In this chapter, it was told that child-centred pedagogy should be their mean of giving primacy to children's experiences, their voices, and their active participation.  But is such kind of pedagogy really being practised in our schools?  As per NCF-2005 chapter, 2 students should take initiatives to do things, to ask questions and to pursue investigations but most of the time chalk and talk method is used and the teacher is always busy to complete the syllabus.  If these things can't be implemented then why we invent such ideas and theories?  
       This chapter focus that children should be provided such kind of environment where they feel they are valued but is it happening?  One of the biggest barriers to the development of a child's thinking abilities is their parents.  They want marks.  They want the 90s and above 90s and the school, teachers, Principals also want this.  Now the child also starts thinking that marks are more important than knowledge.  If marks are important, then see how many marks Mahatma Gandhi got during his schooling.  If marks are important then why J. Krishnamurti refused to get teachings in schools.  If marks are important then think about Sandeep Maheswari who is a college drop out student!  
       Now let us talk about development and learning.  First lets start from a question what is development?  and what is learning?  And what is the difference between development and learning?   Development is the result of learning and learning is a process of our life experiences.  Now let us see how many students have a learning based on their life experience and what kind of development they have now?
     This is the bloody shit system which just wants the 90s not learner, teachers.  They want numbers not knowledge.  Do we think our students are understanding their subject matter deeply or just remembering the facts and forget after examinations?  Is there learning without burden or learning with a burden?

Think!
Think?
Please think.

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

The True journey.

Everyone is going towards a journey,
a journey of eternity,
sometimes walking,
sometimes laughing,
and sometimes crying,
but the journey goes on,
continuously.

It is a journey of time
which never stops for a while.

It is running as if never comes again,
though we are thinking
that the time will come back again,
but it never comes
just like the past.

We meet people,
and talk with them.

Sometime

we like them.

Sometime not,
 but the journey goes on.

It never stops.

Only the Faces are changing,
thoughts are changing,
but still there is something
which never change,
which never change like the old wall,
where people are spiting,
and it looks like a fall,
a fall of eterrnity,
a fall of humanity.

But still the journey goes on,
still the journey goes on.

Look the birds are flying,
look the people are running,
but why are they running?

Why are they running?

I ask from myself again and again.

So I decided why not to ask?

Why not to ask the cause of running?

So I decided to ask a question from me
and then I ask, "Why are you running?"

He said because time is running,
I told him why not to stop the time?

Why not to stop the watch?

He smiles and said,
"It can never be done at all
because life is so small."

I told him again,
"why not to stop
and find the cause?"

He said this journey can never be stopped.
This journey can never be stopped.
Until it never comes to its Lord.
Until it never comes to its Lord.

But who knows if the journey goes on,
but who knows if the journey goes on.



The Education and philosophy

Philosophy and education both are the same things.  Only the difference is that one is shadow and another is a body itself.  Philosophy work as a shadow which provide us the ideas regarding the future implementations in the field of education whereas Education gives it a ground to be implemented at a same time.  In Indian school of thought philosophy means darshan.  Darshan stands for something which guide us to look inside.  Thus philosophy helps us to introspect and guide us what are our weakness and what are its solutions?
       Lets talk about the education of present scenario.  The present education is though having a fine philosophy but it is not implemented at the ground level.  Why so?  The reason is commercialization of education.  Education is something which is not a subject of earning rather it is a subject devoting and sacrificing.  But now education become a business but lead different education institutions towards cut throat competition.  And ultimately the main victim of competition is student and the teacher.  Schools want grades and 100 out of 100 marks whereas for implementing it teachers are forced to make the things happen.  Further teachers force students to learn without understanding as our curriculum is very comprehensive therefore everything is done in wrong manner.  Schools don't bother about the real knowledge as their main concern is marks and grades.  Students also don't bother as the touchstone for their knowledge is their makes and grade.  Now the question is:  Where is education and where is learning and who is a true learner?
       As per the guidelines of NCF-2005 learning should be based on understanding and without burden but tell me very honestly how many students feel burden-less in their learning and how many students able to understand everything completely?  It means NCF-2005 is not implemented at the ground level and cooperative learning is not being emphasized.  Let me predict the future of our country.  In future students have 100 percent marks but having base less.